Skip to content
The Tech Team Performance Review Kit: the guide's first pages, with the review cycle and the rating scale, on a yellow background

The Tech Team Performance Review Kit

Run performance reviews your engineers and IT staff think are fair: editable self-review, manager review, conversation and calibration forms, plus a guide to evidence over memory, calibrating across managers and keeping pay separate.

A bad review costs more than a skipped one. Good engineers leave over reviews that felt unfair, and weak performance goes unaddressed when reviews are vague. Most of it comes from the same few places: last month crowding out the year, managers who rate differently, and pay arriving in the same breath as feedback.

This kit gives you the forms and the process to fix all three - so the review takes an hour and surprises nobody.

What's in it

The forms (one Word file, four parts, every word editable):

  • Self-review: what they delivered and the evidence, how they worked in five areas, what got in their way, and where they want to go next.
  • Manager review: a rating for each area with an example from the whole period, two strengths, one or two things to work on, and readiness for the next level.
  • The review conversation and goals: a 45-minute agenda, notes, and three agreed goals - with a sign-off that means "we talked", not "I agree with every word".
  • Calibration sheet: one row per person, so managers compare ratings against the same expectations before anyone hears theirs.

The five areas match The Tech Career Ladder: technical skill, scope and impact, ownership, communication and teamwork, and helping others grow.

The guide (4 pages):

  • The six-week cycle, and a four-point rating scale with no middle option.
  • Evidence over memory: where it comes from, five ways reviews go wrong and the fix for each, three questions to ask peers, and feedback that names what happened.
  • Calibration: a 60-to-90-minute meeting plan, the rules in the room, the questions to ask, promotions, and why pay comes later.
  • The conversation: what to do when they disagree, the harder cases, words to leave out, and keeping the goals alive afterwards.

Who it's for

CTOs, heads of technology, IT managers and team leads with a few engineers or IT staff to review - and CEOs who want reviews in the tech team to be as fair as anywhere else. You don't need an HR department to use it.

It pairs with The Tech Career Ladder, for levels, readiness and pay bands, and The One-to-One Kit for Tech Managers, where the real feedback happens all year. Hiring next? The Tech Interview Kit scores candidates against the same kind of criteria.

It's a practical guide, not legal or HR advice. If a review could lead to a formal warning or dismissal, follow your HR process and take advice first.

You get two files: the forms in Word format (they also open in Google Docs and Pages) and the 4-page PDF guide.

Want them all? The Complete Collection has every guide in the store in one download, for less than a third of the price.

Reviews

No reviews yet.